2007-2008 (Sophomore Year)
Cross Country: Schaefer competed in four meets for the Pirates. He ran a season best 8k at the SCAC Championships hosted by Southwestern University in a time of 33:37.95, placing 83rd out of 87 runners.

2006-2007 (First Year)
Cross Country: Schaefer competed in seven meets for the Pirates, including three top-5 finish for the team. His highest overall finish was the SU short course where he placed 38th of 54 competitors. He ran the 6k course in 23:29.8. At the Texas Lutheran Invitational, he ran a personal best 8k of 32:23 and placed 59th in a field of 74.